I-DEV0360: Deviation from monitoring plan regarding the quarterly measurement of methane content in the biogas of the biodigester

Reference I-DEV0360
Submitted by DNV (27 Sep 2010)
Project activity 644: Methane Recovery and Electricity Generation Project GCM 8
Selected monitoring period 27 Apr 2007 - 19 Oct 2007
Title/subject of deviation Deviation from monitoring plan regarding the quarterly measurement of methane content in the biogas of the biodigester
Description
According to monitoring plan described in the registered PDD and the methodology AMS-III.D (version 09)
the “amount of methane recovered and used as fuel or combusted shall be monitored, using flow meter and
analysing the methane content of the combusted gases either online, or with samples at least quarterly, and
more frequently if the results show significant deviations from previous values.” However, in the monitoring
period from 27 April 2007 to 19 October 2007 only one measurement of methane content was carried out in 29
September 2007. The monitoring frequency does thus not comply with requirement to have quarterly analysis
as outlined in the monitoring plan and the methodology, as only one measurement was made in the monitoring
period, a request of deviation is required.
A statistical analysis of the methane content analyses was performed, including the measurement made on 29
September 2007 and two measurements made in the subsequent monitoring period on 23 December 2008 and
19 January 2009. Using the monitored data available (3 measurement points) and in compliance with the
Guidelines to calculate the fraction of methane in the landfill gas from periodical measurements used as
reference for the similarity of the calculation presented in this deviation, a standard deviation was calculated
with a 95% of confidence interval (refer to spreadsheet GCM8 CH4_95%Cl_3samples.xls)
The lower bound value (68.85%) of the 95% confidence interval was for this site found to be higher than the
lowest measurement (68.77%). Hence, the project participants proposed to apply the lowest measurement
(68.77%) as the methane content for the whole monitoring period. Using this value results in a conservative
determination of the project’s emission reductions.
Assessment
Since December 2008, the project participant complies with the requirement to have quarterly methane content
measurement. The deviation is thus only applicable to the monitoring period in question, and the deviation
does not require a revision of the monitoring plan and any amendment of the methodology AMS-III.D
Impact
The methane content applied to the whole monitoring period is the lowest methane content measured during the monitoring period in question. Hence, the deviation is expected to rather result in an underestimation of the
emission reductions.
Annexes EB 48_Annex13 - Guidelines to calculate the fraction of methane - meth_guid36.pdf (193 KB)
GCM8 CH4_95%CI_3samples.xlsx (38 KB)
Link to the documentation made available at validation stage or monitoring report Link to relevant documentation
Signed form Signed form (359 KB)
Decision This request for deviation has been accepted.

The Chairs have accepted the proposed request for deviation to the monitoring and reporting process for the first and the second monitoring period.

Current status 15 Dec 2010 - Deviation accepted
Historic statuses 27 Sep 2010 - Submission received
25 Oct 2010 - Successfully passed the Completeness Check
04 Nov 2010 - Awaiting DOE input
16 Nov 2010 - Clarifications received
30 Nov 2010 - Awaiting EB decision

Clarifications

2 clarification(s) provided on 16 Nov 2010
dev0360- form (70 KB)
dev0360 samples (21 KB)