Super Critical technology based thermal power generation at Andhra Pradesh, India
[]
Host party(ies) India
Methodology(ies) ACM0013 ver. 4
Standardised Baselines N/A
Estimated annual reductions* 969,552
Start date of first crediting period. 01 Dec 12
Length of first crediting period. 10 years
DOE/AE Bureau Veritas India Pvt. Ltd.
Period for comments 28 Sep 11 - 27 Oct 11
PP(s) for which DOE have a contractual obligation M/s. Krishnapatnam Power Corporation Limited
The operational/applicant entity working on this project has decided to make the Project Design Document (PDD) publicly available directly on the UNFCCC CDM website.
PDD PDD (1079 KB)
Local stakeholder consultation report: N/A
Impact assessment summary: N/A
Submission of comments to the DOE/AE Compilation of submitted inputs:
The discussion and dismissal of alternatives are not in compliance with the Methodology. As per the Methodology alternatives can be excluded only if they are not in compliant with all applicable legal and regulatory requirements. Alternatives which are compliant with applicable legal and regulatory requirements, The CDM-PDD should submit for validation a clear comparison of the financial indicator for all scenario alternatives. The reasons cited for dismissal of alternatives is not conforming to methodological requirements though it saves the consultant from the trouble of providing calculation. The presentation does not satisfy ACM 0013

Reasons given for dismissing the alternatives like diesel / gas/ naphtha do not seem to conform to methodology.  Power generation using Nuclear technology is not available to private investor is not a correct statement. The Indian Atomic Energy Act - 1962 permits private participation but with majority Government participation

Therefore, restricting the alternatives to sub critical (probably imported coal as nowhere it is stated whether it is pit head, linkage or imported coal based plant) is not correct. The alternatives does not even cover other possible alternatives of sub critical plant like pit head and linkage coal. Pp/Consultant should read the methodology and strictly follow it. Considering only one alternative is not correct.

Super critical power plant cost is more than 1.5 times the cost of sub critical plant. Projects already registered do not exhibit this high difference. Moreover, it is not known how the PP can set up sub critical plant at a cost of Rs.30 mn./MW, when the Expert Committee on Fuels has suggested a cost of Rs.40 mn. MW as late as 2007 With such a cost difference, no doubt, the project will be additional. 

Moreover, the company’s brochure states, “Navayuga is developing an imported coal based 2,120MW mega power project at Krishnapatnam near its Krishnapatnam Port in the Nellore District, Andhra Pradesh. The estimated cost of the project is Rs. 85 billion. The station will comprise 2 units of 660MW supercritical power generating units in phase I and an 800MW supercritical generating unit in Phase II.” (see http://www.navayugagrp.com/pdf/nec_e-brochure.pdf). As per this, the cost is only Rs.40 mn./MW, while the PDD considers Rs.54 mn./MW.  While the company’s website places the installed capacity at 2100 MW, PDD has taken installed capacity of 1980 MW.   In case the PP claims that this cost of sub critical power plant, then the cost assumed for sub critical power plant (at Rs.30 mn./MW) is incorrect; alternatively, if this cost is that of super critical power plant then the cost of super critical power plant given (Rs.54 mn./MW) is incorrect. 
 
PDD states, “This Supercritical technology also enables high standard of operational performance with lesser auxiliary power consumption, lesser make-up water consumption, and no secondary oil support after 30% Maximum Continuous Rating”. On the other hand, in the input parameters given, auxiliary consumption has been taken at 7.5% for both sub critical and project activity. Secondary oil consumption is taken at 2 ml/kWh for both sub critical and project activity. Moreover, the secondary oil consumption as per published reports is much less, i.e., only about 0.15 ml/kWh. 

Additionality is demonstrated using Levelised cost of electricity cost. Is levelised cost is considered appropriate financial indicator for the project type and decision making context? Does the company evaluate projects based on levelised cost? Will the company go ahead with the project if the project is loss making though the LECP is lower than the other alternative? Moreover, proving additionality with LECP  does not satisfy additionality tool or the methodology

When the average PLF achieved by the power plants including public sector power plants is 93%, what is the basis of considering 80% PLF for a project in private sector?

This does not appear to be a bid based project. There is no information on how the company is envisages selling power. There appears to be no reason as to why the company cannot sell the power at a cost which will enable it to operate without CDM benefits. 

Common practice analysis states that there are no operating super critical projects in India which is incorrect. And closing common practice analysis only with these words is not correct. 
Submitted by: Karthikeyan

Comment (602 KB) submitted by: Sergey Firsov on behalf of Steve Herz, Sierra Club


The comment period is over.
* Emission reductions in metric tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum that are based on the estimates provided by the project participants in unvalidated PDDs