Grid connected renewable power generation at Tamil Nadu, India
[]
Host party(ies) India
Methodology(ies) AMS-I.D. ver. 17
Standardised Baselines N/A
Estimated annual reductions* 8,072
Start date of first crediting period. 01 Feb 12
Length of first crediting period. 10 years
DOE/AE TÜV NORD CERT GmbH
Period for comments 30 Aug 11 - 28 Sep 11
PP(s) for which DOE have a contractual obligation Dalmia Laminators Limited
The operational/applicant entity working on this project has decided to make the Project Design Document (PDD) publicly available directly on the UNFCCC CDM website.
PDD PDD (765 KB)
Local stakeholder consultation report: N/A
Impact assessment summary: N/A
Submission of comments to the DOE/AE Compilation of submitted inputs:
PP/consultant has chosen Power Index as the representative of stock prices of power generating companies. Though PDD does not state the source of this data, it is evident that it is BSE Power index. PP has taken opening index for January and February 2010 and closing index for the rest of the months and the reasons not known.

Did PP/Consultant check the composition of Power Index and whether it contains only power generating companies? The fact is that the weight assigned for power generating companies in the index is hardly 25%. How can this index be used to compute the expected return on power generating companies?

When the index is based on price movement of constituent stock in BSE, how can it be regressed on S&P CNX 500 and Nifty? Though any two variables can have a correlation, in Statistics it is called ‘spurious correlation’ and has no value at all. PP/consultant should know atleast this much before using the model. What is the logic or basis for using only one year observations? 

When the PP/consultant provides scholarly presentation on CAPM by quoting Aswath Damodaran, did the PP/consultant read Aswath Damodaran’s books and articles in full at all? Does Aswath Damodaran recommend using 10 year observation to calculate market return?

On what basis the unlevered beta is used? 

PP/consultant does not seem to know the difference between expected return on equity and WACC at all! While the PDD states that WACC has been used as benchmark, what is used is the expected return on equity. Both are different. Expected return on equity is only a component of WACC. 

Since when Tamil Nadu windmills started giving PLF as low as 24%? Annex 11, EB 48 is one the most abused guidelines by PP and DOE alike. It is very easy to get the PLF report for any PLF. PP invariably gives lower PLF, as the project will not be attracted by Annex 67, EB 48, because PLF is not within control of PP. DOE, in their anxiety to get the project registered, accept this PLF. Did DOE go through the PLF assumed by other projects located in Tamil Nadu webhosted by it?  Can DOE accept two different PLFs for two different projects?
  
The cost is reported to be based on offer letters. How much did the Project developer actually pay? Quotation can be obtained for any cost. Hence, quotation is not correct though guidance 6 will be cited as the reason. DOE should read the entire VVM before citing guidance 6. In CDM projects, PP gets higher quotes to make the project additional. DOE is required to use its knowledge. PP should be asked to take purchase order cost and not offer letter cost. 

The windmills are eligible for 100% depreciation and tax holiday for 10 years. Since the windmills are part of the company, it will save tax due to depreciation. If this is taken into account, the IRR should be much higher.
Submitted by: Karthikeyan


The comment period is over.
* Emission reductions in metric tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum that are based on the estimates provided by the project participants in unvalidated PDDs