Hydro Power Project at Romai
[]
Host party(ies) India
Methodology(ies) ACM0002 ver. 12
Standardised Baselines N/A
Estimated annual reductions* 156,443
Start date of first crediting period. 01 Apr 14
Length of first crediting period. 10 years
DOE/AE DNV-CUK
Period for comments 13 Apr 11 - 12 May 11
PP(s) for which DOE have a contractual obligation Tangnu Romai Power Generation Private Limited
The operational/applicant entity working on this project has decided to make the Project Design Document (PDD) publicly available directly on the UNFCCC CDM website.
PDD PDD (299 KB)
Local stakeholder consultation report: N/A
Impact assessment summary: N/A
Submission of comments to the DOE/AE Compilation of submitted inputs:
1.	When is the board meeting and date of investment decision? It is not explicitly mentioned in the PDD.  
2.	Why the alternative P3 (All other plausible and credible alternatives to the project activity that provide an increase in the power generated at the site, which are technically feasible to implement. This includes, inter alia, different levels of replacement and/or retrofit at the power plant/unit(s). Only alternatives available to project participants should be taken into account.) is not discussed in the PDD.
3.	Why barrier analysis is not discussed in the PDD. If there is no barrier, then it should be mentioned in the PDD. 
4.	The Meth mentions that if investment analysis option is used, apply the following: 
a)	Apply an investment comparison analysis, as per Step 3 of the .Combined tool to identify the baseline scenario and demonstrate additionality., if more than one alternative is remaining after Step 2 and if the remaining alternatives include scenarios P1 and P3;
b)	Apply a benchmark analysis, as per Step 2b of the .Tool for the demonstration and assessment of additionality. If more than one alternative is remaining after Step 2 and if the remaining alternatives include scenarios P1 and P2.
But PP failed to apply like this. Pls. clarify.
5.	How benchmark is calculated and how IRR is calculated is not discussed at all in the PDD. The value of 2.19% for stage 3 project seems to be wrong.
6.	PLF should be based on EB48 Annex 11guideline which says The plant load factor provided to banks and/or equity financiers while applying the project activity for project financing, or to When is the board meeting and date of investment decision? It is not explicitly mentioned in the PDD.  
7.	Why the alternative P3 (All other plausible and credible alternatives to the project activity that provide an increase in the power generated at the site, which are technically feasible to implement. This includes, inter alia, different levels of replacement and/or retrofit at the power plant/unit(s). Only alternatives available to project participants should be taken into account.) is not discussed in the PDD.
8.	Why barrier analysis is not discussed in the PDD. If there is no barrier, then it should be mentioned in the PDD. 
9.	The Meth mentions that if investment analysis option is used, apply the following: 
c)	Apply an investment comparison analysis, as per Step 3 of the .Combined tool to identify the baseline scenario and demonstrate additionality., if more than one alternative is remaining after Step 2 and if the remaining alternatives include scenarios P1 and P3;
d)	Apply a benchmark analysis, as per Step 2b of the .Tool for the demonstration and assessment of additionality. If more than one alternative is remaining after Step 2 and if the remaining alternatives include scenarios P1 and P2.
But PP failed to apply like this. Pls. clarify.
10.	How benchmark is calculated and how IRR is calculated is not discussed at all in the PDD. The value of 2.19% for stage 3 project seems to be wrong.
11.	PLF should be based on EB48 Annex 11guideline which says The plant load factor provided to banks and/or equity financiers while applying the project activity for project financingthe government while applying the project activity for implementation approval; (b) The plant load factor determined by a third party contracted by the project participants (e.g. an engineering company); But PDD doesn’t demonstrate how PLF has been arrived at. 
12.	Whether PLF includes machine shutdown, machine availability. Whether grid availability is accounted for in the calculation of gross generation. To my surprise, critical parameter like PLF is missing from the PDD. How DOE has allowed this. 
13.	Common practice analysis should be based on EB 39 Annex 10 (Additionality tool). Each step of common practice analysis should be fulfilled as per tool.
14.	Emission reduction calculation should be based on EB 50 Annex 14 “Tool for emission factor for the electricity system.
15.	Whether only one set of main meter, check meter set is enough for three projects. The monitoring parameters need to be checked by DOE.
The main meter and check meter technical parameters like accuracy level, make, etc. needs to be mentioned in the PDD. 


Submitted by: lawrance


The comment period is over.
* Emission reductions in metric tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum that are based on the estimates provided by the project participants in unvalidated PDDs