Thermal power generation using less GHG intensive technology
[]
Host party(ies) India
Methodology(ies) ACM0013 ver. 4
Standardised Baselines N/A
Estimated annual reductions* 516,439
Start date of first crediting period. 01 Apr 15
Length of first crediting period. 10 years
DOE/AE SGS-UKL
Period for comments 16 Jul 11 - 14 Aug 11
PP(s) for which DOE have a contractual obligation CESC Limited
The operational/applicant entity working on this project has decided to make the Project Design Document (PDD) publicly available directly on the UNFCCC CDM website.
PDD PDD (479 KB)
Local stakeholder consultation report: N/A
Impact assessment summary: N/A
Submission of comments to the DOE/AE Compilation of submitted inputs:
Comment (265 KB) submitted by: Justin Guay on behalf of Justin Guay, Sierra Club

The discussion and dismissal of alternatives are not in compliance with the Methodology. As per the Methodology alternatives can be excluded only if they are not in compliant with all applicable legal and regulatory requirements. Alternatives which are compliant with applicable legal and regulatory requirements, The CDM-PDD should submit for validation a clear comparison of the financial indicator for all scenario alternatives. The reasons cited for dismissal of alternatives is not conforming to methodological requirements though it saves the consultant from the trouble of providing calculation. The presentation does not satisfy ACM 0013

High operational cost barrier on account of spiralling price is not given as one of the acceptable reasons for dismissing the alternative in the methodology. Therefore, omission of diesel / fuel/ naphtha is not conforming to methodology. 

There is no statement on nuclear power at all. In sum, the alternatives covered is not exhaustive and does not conform to methodology 

The company’s presentation, which is available in public domain states, “Future expansion to include alternate fuel like Gas & Nuclear” while in the PDD gas alternative has been dismissed due to non-availability and nuclear alternative is not discussed at all. 

Therefore, restricting the alternatives to sub critical (probably linkage plant as nowhere it is stated whether it is pit head, linkage or imported coal based plant) is not correct. The alternatives does not even cover other possible alternatives of sub critical plant like pit head and imported coal. Consultant should read the methodology and strictly follow it. Considering only one alternative is not correct

The presentation mentions about 3 sub critical plants located in Maharashtra, Haldia and Jharkhand – the cost of which is Rs.50 mn./MW. In the PDD the cost considered for sub critical power plant is Rs.30 mn.!! 2 X 500 MW is comparable size and methodology does not require the alternatives should be exactly of the same capacity. Since this project is located in coal belt, this project should have been compared and not what the CERC has approved. When the company itself cannot set up sub critical power plant in the coal belt at a cost less than Rs.50 mn., how can PP claim that the project can be completed in Rs.30 mn.” Incidentally, Expert committee report on fuels has projected a cost of Rs.40 mn./MW way back in 2004. The cost could not have come down over years. Published literature indicates that the difference between sub critical and super critical technology is only 10 to 15%. Hence, the cost of Rs.30mn/MW is not correct and should not be accepted. The sub critical plant has been taken at Rs.30 mn. to render the project additional. Please see the presentation
http://www.cescltd.com/cesc/web/investor/helpdesk/document/CESC%20-%20July10.pdf 
 
Additionality is demonstrated using LECP. Is LECP is considered appropriate financial indicator for the project type and decision making context? Does the company evaluate projects based on LECP? Will the company go ahead with the project if the project is loss making though the LECP is lower than the other alternative? CESC is a publicly listed company and it is doubtful whether any shareholder will buy such an argument. Moreover, proving additionality with LECP  does not satisfy additionality tool or the methodology

PDD does not state whether the power will be sold directly by CESC or sold to grid. If it sells to grid the tariff will be determined by LECP. If it is selling directly to customers/ third party sale or wheeling power to adjoiing state where it is a DISCOM, then the tariff should be the average tariff at which it sells power to public. It is stated as Rs.4.57/kWh in 2010. The presentation states that the company has got long term open access from Power Grid and hence, the power is being wheeled to West Bengal for distribution in the distribution area of CESC. DOE should check this and if the PP states that it is selling to grid, then an undertaking should be taken from PP and this clearly in the validation report.

The debt equity ratio given in the PDD and the presentation is different. How can the debt component come down from what has been given in the presentation?

When the average PLF achieved by the power plants including public sector power plants is 93%, what is the basis of considering 85% PLF for a project in private sector?

Common practice analysis states that there are no operating super critical projects in India which is incorrect. And closing common practice analysis only with these words is not correct. 
Submitted by: Karthikeyan


The comment period is over.
* Emission reductions in metric tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum that are based on the estimates provided by the project participants in unvalidated PDDs