Replacement of electricity generated by existing 4 subcritical units of 120 MW of Koradi TPS by 1 unit of 660 MW based on supercritical technology
[]
Host party(ies) India
Methodology(ies) ACM0013 ver. 4
Standardised Baselines N/A
Estimated annual reductions* 215,184
Start date of first crediting period. 01 Dec 15
Length of first crediting period. 10 years
DOE/AE Bureau Veritas India Pvt. Ltd.
Period for comments 10 May 11 - 08 Jun 11
PP(s) for which DOE have a contractual obligation Maharashtra State Power Generation Company Limited
The operational/applicant entity working on this project has decided to make the Project Design Document (PDD) publicly available directly on the UNFCCC CDM website.
PDD PDD (1129 KB)
Local stakeholder consultation report: N/A
Impact assessment summary: N/A
Submission of comments to the DOE/AE Compilation of submitted inputs:
It is evident from the PDD that the values are consistent and it is definitely forged and cooked up values to show a non CDM project as a CDM project. What is this? DoE to check the Detailed Project Report and Feasibility Report which is submitted to the other agencies and Banks by Project owner and ensure that the values match with the DPR/FR  submitted to DoE also. After careful study of PDD it is found that DPR/FR is in different versions made and submitted with different purposes to different agencies which is totally unacceptable, illegal and unethical. PP/Consultant may show some undertaking letter from bank manager to DoE stating that both DPR’s are same. These kinds of letters should not be accepted and entertained by DoE. While collecting the DPR/FR from banks and other agencies, all DPR/FR pages should be counter signed by Banks and other agencies so that the real DPR/FR given to other parties by the PP/Consultant is same as the one submitted to DOE. In this particular project there is clear cut evidence that DPR/FR values are changed/ fabricated mischievously and intentionally. This must be probed fully. DOE must take a written undertaking from the PP/Consultant about the list of parties to whom this DPR/FR is submitted and for what purposes. Then DOE should cross check with all the parties and confirm that the same DPR/FR is submitted to all the parties correctly without any changes. DOE must not accept any reports and undertakings from PP/Consultant. DOE must make independent evaluation and use totally different parties without informing the PP or Consultant to cross check the facts. DOE to write to the party who prepared the DPR/FR which is submitted to the banks and other agencies and the same is verified against the one submitted to the DOE by PP/Consultant. This project is a fabricated and fake CDM project and must be rejected by the DOE right away. DOE should not support this kind of projects otherwise CDM EB should suspend this DOE for at least one year. 
Submitted by: zhong zhou li

PP is replacing a subcritical plant with a supercrtical plant as it is a special case compared to other Indian supercritical plants.

pdd says four units of 120 megawatts each would be replaced with a new 660 megawatt unit. please take a declaration from PP and submit it to CDM executive board that the 4 units would be made non-operational and not put for ANY commercial use anywhere before new 660 gets commissioned. Otherwise both existing plant as well as new plant continue to operate not leading to any replacement. 

Baseline plants with 480 megawatts capacity would be REPLACED with 660 mega watt plant. this means additional capacity CREATION of 37.5% & additional net electricity too (at least by  37.5% i assume). how are CERs calculated. since project is a replacement project, baseline emissions of 480 megawatt should be offset against project emissions of 660 megawatts. per megawatthour baseline emissions is not a right appraoch because baseline emission number used  INCLUDE the emissions from 480 megawatts too. doe should ensure calculations are done to include the offsetting. if consultant or pp does not agree with the capacity offsetting approach, i suggest you to write to METH and ask how the additional 37.5% capacity should be treated.
Submitted by: GS

Dear Sir,

Please take into consideration the following comments while validating the project:

1.	When the project is 3 X 660 MW, what is the objective of considering only 1X660 MW? Is the purpose to see whether this project goes through so that other two projects can also be web hosted! 
2.	The argument ‘first-of-its-kind’ proves that the PP is not aware of the super critical project which has already commenced generation. The project can never be the first of its kind
3.	Sub critical power plant efficiency is stated to be 28 to 33%. This is totally incorrect. The highest efficiency achieved is more than 35%.
4.	How does the barrier analysis conform to Annex 13, EB 50? The said annex specifically states that lack of trained staff cannot be construed as barrier. The consultant does not seem to have read the guidelines
5.	Where is it stated that the PP 'not having sufficient familiarity with operating technology' is a prevailing practice barrier? It appears that PWC has not read the Additionality Tool. 
6.	Common practice analysis states that there are no operating super critical power plants in India, which is factually incorrect
7.	The project cost of Rs.6 core/MW is very high. See other web hosted projects. None of the other projects has projected such high cost. The objective seems to be to make the project additional somehow.
8.	The start date is stated as 23rd Sept. 2011 and the commencement date is given as December 2014. How can the implementation period be 6 years? Does PWC knows how to count years or is it done to make the project additional? 
9.	On what basis PLF has been taken as 80%? Several sub critical projects have achieved PLF of more than 95% and a few projects have achieved more than 100%. Therefore, PLF of 80% should be not be accepted.
10.	On what basis auxiliary consumption for the project activity is taken at 8% in the first year and 7.5% from second year onwards? L&T for its own project has taken auxiliary consumption of only 6%. The consultant seems to have modified every figure to make a non-additional project additional. 
11.	When L&T has considered station heat rate of 2082 kcal/kWh, on what basis heat rate has been considered at 2130 kcal/kWh? This is one more method adopted by the consultant to make the project additional!
12.	PWC has adopted every method possible and conceivable to make the project additional. Besides, cost, PLF, heat rate, auxiliary consumption, the next thing they have chosen is depreciation. DOE should check from the Annual reports of MAHAGENCO whether the company adopts the book depreciation rate given in the PDD. No company will adopt a lower depreciation rate and increase the tax outflow. This has been done only to reduce the cash inflow and make the project additional. DOE should not accept this.
13.	What about the tax saving likely to be enjoyed by the company on account of depreciation. The project is eligible for 35% depreciation (15% + 20%) depreciation in the first year and 15% from second year. DOE should ensure that the tax saving is reckoned as cash inflow while computing financial indicator and the calculations take into account tax holiday
14.	On what basis levelized cost is used as financial indicator. Please read the Additionality Tool. It states the financial indicator should be appropriate for the project type and decision making context. Will any company take a decision based on levelised unit cost? This is unbelievable and unacceptable. PWC does not want to use IRR because the project will become non additional. DOE should insist on IRR. 
15.	Where is the question of providing for 60 days receivable? DOE should check the PPA and see the payment term by DISCOM. It cannot be 60 days. 
16.	When L&T has considered GCV of coal at more than 4000 kcal/kg. Why should this project consider 3800 kcal/kg? DOE should check where from the coal is sourced, what is the CV of coal already purchased by the company before accepting this CV. It is low
17.	For a project located more than 2000 Kms away from pithead, L&T has considered  coal cost of about Rs.1800/MT, whereas this project located very close to coal mines takes Rs.2452/MT. The cost is very high. DOE should not accept this cost
18.	Does the consultant ever read what is the secondary fuel consumption of power plants in the country. It is 0.15 ml/kWh. Where is 0.15 ml/kWh and 4.5 ml/kWh? Has L&T assumed 4.5 ml/kWh for its proposal?
19.	The sub critical plant cost has been considered at Rs.2.65 cr/MW while the project cost is Rs.6 cr./MW. Which project will not become additional with this cost difference!! Expert committee on fuels has recommended a cost of Rs.4 cr./MW in August 2004. This project is conceived in August 2008, though the consultant has intelligently chosen not to give the decision making date so that it can be modified for benchmark and also to overcome conformity problem to annex 22, EB 49. Anyway, it should be after 2004. How can the project cost be Rs.2.65 cr./MW? 
20.	Why should the sub critical plant size be 2000 MW when the project size is only 660 MW? Has the Consultant read the methodology properly?
21.	When L&T considers O&M cost of only Rs.8.5 lakhs/MW, this project considers the O&M cost of Rs.13.9 lakhs/MW. How can it be accepted?
22.	The funniest part is when the sub critical plant costs Rs.2.65 cr., project activity costs Rs.6 cr., NG plant costs Rs.6.03 cr/MW!! The consultant has chosen the easiest way to eliminate the NG alternative by hiking the price so high. Expert committee has recommended a cost of less than Rs.3 crore.MW. 
23.	The PDD states that the implementation period of NG plant is 63 months! Do the NG plant take 5 years for implementation? 
24.	Please let me know where do you get NG plant with 550 MW capacity? Are there any plant with this capacity? 
25.	The consultant has introduced ROE for LUC calculation. DOE should remove this because the cost difference between project activity and alternative is so much that the project is rendered artificially additional by considering ROE. ROE is not a cost. DOE should remove the ROE and then calculate the LUC. Whatever the consultant has done is totally incorrect

In sum, the project is not additional and the consultant has made the project additional using an incorrect financial indicator and incorrect input parameters. When DOE goes through carefully each of the input parameters, it will understand that the project is made additional. 

Yours sincerely
Karthikeyan 
Submitted by: Karthikeyan

Comment (204 KB) submitted by: Antonia Vorner on behalf of Pravin Mote & Nishant Mate

Comment (46 KB) submitted by: nishant mate on behalf of Nishant Mate Nagpur (nishant24@gmail.com) and Pravin Mote nagpur (pravin.mote@gmail.com)

Comment (71 KB) submitted by: Antonia Vorner on behalf of Vidarbha Environmental Action Group

Comment (150 KB) Submitted by: Shane Rattenbury

Comment (1398 KB) submitted by: Sergey Firsov on behalf of CDM Watch and the Sierra Club


The comment period is over.
* Emission reductions in metric tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum that are based on the estimates provided by the project participants in unvalidated PDDs