4.2 MW Wind Power Project by National Enterprises at Tamil Nadu, India
[]
Host party(ies) India
Methodology(ies) AMS-I.D. ver. 17
Standardised Baselines N/A
Estimated annual reductions* 9,151
Start date of first crediting period. 01 Nov 11
Length of first crediting period. 10 years
DOE/AE TÜV NORD CERT GmbH
Period for comments 05 Aug 11 - 03 Sep 11
PP(s) for which DOE have a contractual obligation National Enterprises
The operational/applicant entity working on this project has decided to make the Project Design Document (PDD) publicly available directly on the UNFCCC CDM website.
PDD PDD (556 KB)
Local stakeholder consultation report: N/A
Impact assessment summary: N/A
Submission of comments to the DOE/AE Compilation of submitted inputs:
The cost of equity of 20.58% is very high. PDD does not give what is the duration considered for computing beta and what is the return interval selected, why BSE 500 has been selected for market return, what is the cut off date selected for beta computation etc. PDD attempts to teach the global stakeholders instead of giving information and thereby conceals the information. It is not clear how the DOE allowed the PP to web host this project. TNERC has recommended a post tax return of only 13.25% (19.85% pre tax return with 33.22% tax will yield only 13.25% post tax return). If the PP states that this is the return the project expects then it is subjective return and as per guidance 13, “If the project could be developed by a different entity the unwillingness of one investor to assume the associated risks is not sufficient evidence that the project is additional, as this may be based on the subjective profit expectations of that investor”. If the DOE is aware of this regulation, it should not accept the subjective return. DOE could have atleast compared the default return given by EB before web hosting. The return cannot exceed whatever EB has suggested. 

PDD does not state anywhere about the financing pattern of the project. If the project is financed by debt and equity, then DOE should not accept equity IRR if the project is financed by debt and equity. DOE should check the annual report of the company and ensure that the project is financed only by equity if the PP claims so.

Wind projects in Thirunelveli District have achieved PLF of more than 30%. What is the PP/consultant talking about 26%? PP/consultant want to make the project additional and hence assumed lower PLF. DOE should not accept PLF less than 27.15% recommended by TNERC. It should check the PLF achieved by this project.

Suzlon never charges Rs.18 to 19 lakhs for 2.1 MW windmill if we go by other registered projects. O&M cost is high. All input parameters are based on offer letters as per PDD. PP is conveniently using guidance 6, Annex 5, EB 62 to support the assumptions. But DOE is expected to use its sectoral and local expertise and financial knowledge as per VVM. Again VVM also states that DOE should not omit any evidence if it impacts additionality. Unfortunately, another project with same configuration with almost near start date is also on the web, “Proposed 4.2 Wind power project” by Vikram Traders. How unreliable the offer letters can be will be seen if the PDD of both the projects are compared. Though the cost in this case is lower, the fact is that offer letters are not appropriate for additionality proving. DOE should go by purchase orders and not by offer letter. 

The purchase order is issued in August. Therefore the project must have started operation in 2010-11 itself. The cash generation during 2010-11 should be deducted from the capital cost and net cost should be taken for calculating IRR.  

This project is eligible for 100% depreciation and tax holiday for first 10 years. The project developer will also save tax due to depreciation. It is not clear whether this is taken into account at all.   
Submitted by: Karthikeyan


The comment period is over.
* Emission reductions in metric tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum that are based on the estimates provided by the project participants in unvalidated PDDs