LDC cogeneration project at Rio Brilhante Mill
[]
Host party(ies) Brazil
Methodology(ies) ACM0006 ver. 10
Standardised Baselines N/A
Estimated annual reductions* 66,320
Start date of first crediting period. 01 Mar 10
Length of first crediting period. 7 years
DOE/AE Bureau Veritas India Pvt. Ltd.
Period for comments 13 Mar 10 - 11 Apr 10
PP(s) for which DOE have a contractual obligation LDC Bioenergia S/A
The operational/applicant entity working on this project has decided to make the Project Design Document (PDD) publicly available directly on the UNFCCC CDM website.
PDD PDD (205 KB)
Local stakeholder consultation report: N/A
Impact assessment summary: N/A
Submission of comments to the DOE/AE Compilation of submitted inputs:
Dear Reader  

The comment below was posted for the following cogeneration projects (involving sugar cane bagasse combustion) in Brazil: 

-	Guaíra bagasse cogeneration efficiency project
-	LDC cogeneration project at Rio Brilhante Mill
-	Lagoa da Prata cogeneration project

I would like to call the attention that no spreadsheet showing the financial calculations for the demonstration of the so-called “additionality” is enclosed to the PDD made available for comments. Thus, it is impossible to visualize how fair and correct is the financial analysis used as a basis for the claiming of the so-called “additionality” of the project In the context of the emerging sugar cane industry in Brazil, with significantly foreign direct investment (FDI) not only for mergers& acquisitions but also for notably huge capacity expansions, it is hilarious to see that one can say that a project like this one faces investment barriers!!! How can all these big multinational companies face difficulties to raise capital for investment with so much available capital sources for investments in clean energy in the global major developed and structured financial markets?   

It is interesting to note that while it is assumed that a so-called “less efficient” power plant would anyway be built in the absence of the proposed project activity, the financial calculation should thus have to necessarily be developed in a way that ONLY the associated incremental CAPEX required for building and operating a more efficient power plant is evaluated against  the also incremental revenues associated with sales of excess electricity generated by the more efficient power plant (under the CDM project context) from the IPP cogeneration plant. Assuming that steam to be generated by the project is also required for the sugar/ethanol mill in both the project and baseline scenario, it is thus completely not fair to consider the TOTAL required investment in equipment (boiler, turbines, pipelines, etc) neither the TOTAL O&M costs associated with the power plant in the IRR calculation. The correct rationale is that the cogeneration project CAPEX is expected to be remunerated both by electricity and steam generation! By taking into account that equivalent amount of steam generation is required both under baseline and project context (as required by the CDM methodology), I am convinced that, if the IRR calculation for the project is indeed correctly calculated (by only considering the incremental start-up costs and O&M costs (difference between the project’s more efficient (and thus more costly) power plant and the baseline less efficient power plant) ), the calculated IRR will be significantly higher than the value presented in the PDD! It is obvious! It is kind of basics of corporate finance that the IRR FOR INCREMENTAL INVESTMENT (NOT TOTAL INVESTMENT) from choosing the larger/more efficient project instead of the smaller/less efficient project is to the type of analysis to be carried out. The incremental cash flows are the differences between the cash flows of larger/more efficient project and those of the smaller / less efficient project. 

Chatrapati Smarak Shivaji 
Madras School of Economics 
Chennai, India
shivaji_mse@hotmail.com
Submitted by: Chatrapati Smarak Shivaji


The comment period is over.
* Emission reductions in metric tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum that are based on the estimates provided by the project participants in unvalidated PDDs