Wind Power Project by Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. (EKIESL-CDM.May-12-01)
[]
Host party(ies) India
Methodology(ies) AMS-I.D. ver. 17
Standardised Baselines N/A
Estimated annual reductions* 2,981
Start date of first crediting period. 18 Aug 12
Length of first crediting period. 7 years
DOE/AE URSCert
Period for comments 20 Jul 12 - 18 Aug 12
PP(s) for which DOE have a contractual obligation Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd.
The operational/applicant entity working on this project has decided to make the Project Design Document (PDD) publicly available directly on the UNFCCC CDM website.
PDD PDD (460 KB)
Local stakeholder consultation report: N/A
Impact assessment summary: N/A
Submission of comments to the DOE/AE Compilation of submitted inputs: 
- Please explain location selection criteria
- Does project owner had any kind of wind based energy business experience?
- How many skilled/unskilled people from surrounding area were employed at this project during commissioning and operation as mentioned in social well being section? 
- Stakeholder meeting for Kutch WEG was carried out in 2008, which can not be valid now. 
- What is Complaint redress mechanism of a company, in case of villagers want to complain about wind mills?
From
Mahesh Pandya
Environmental Engineer
Paryavaran mitra
502, Raj Avenue, Bhaikakanagar road
Thaltej, Ahmedabad – 380059 India
Telefax - 079-26851321/1801
Submitted by: paryavaranmitra 
Gujarat forum on CDM respectfully submit the following comments on the Project Design Document (PDD) for Wind Power Project by Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. At village : Vanchhu, Dist: Jamnagar and village: Kuchhadi, Dist:  Porbandar, Gujarat state, India.

1.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Organized before 5 year - Stakeholder meeting for Jamnagar WEG was carried out in 2008, which can not be valid now. 
2.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Invitation method is not proper - Stakeholders were invited through invitation letter (delivered in hand) which was not a good method to involve stakeholders in the process. Local stakeholder consultation must be carried out neutrally and must involve all the stakeholders.
3.	Employment Opportunity: How many skilled/unskilled people from surrounding area were employed at this project during commissioning and operation as mentioned in social well being section? 
4.	Complain redress mechanism: What is Complaint redress mechanism of a company, in case of villagers want to complain about wind mills?
5.	Location Criteria: Please explain location selection criteria.
6.	Letter of Approval: The letter of approval from host country is basic step for every CDM project and in PDD there is no letter attached. PDD says, “The letter of approval from the party involved in the project activity is not available at the time of submitting the PDD to the validating DOE.”  So in absence of approval letter the whole process turns void.

Falguni Joshi 
Gujarat forum On CDM (gujaratforumoncdm@gmail.com) 
(Gujarat Forum on CDM – is a network of Individuals & Organisations working on Environmental issue & Monitoring of CDM projects in Gujarat, India.)
Submitted by: Gujarat Forum on CDM 
Gujarat forum on CDM respectfully submit the following comments on the Project Design Document (PDD) for Wind Power Project by Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. At village : Vanchhu, Dist: Jamnagar and village: Kuchhadi, Dist:  Porbandar, Gujarat state, India.

1.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Organized before 5 year - Stakeholder meeting for Jamnagar WEG was carried out in 2008, which can not be valid now. 
2.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Invitation method is not proper - Stakeholders were invited through invitation letter (delivered in hand) which was not a good method to involve stakeholders in the process. Local stakeholder consultation must be carried out neutrally and must involve all the stakeholders.
3.	Employment Opportunity: How many skilled/unskilled people from surrounding area were employed at this project during commissioning and operation as mentioned in social well being section? 
4.	Complain redress mechanism: What is Complaint redress mechanism of a company, in case of villagers want to complain about wind mills?
5.	Location Criteria: Please explain location selection criteria.
6.	Letter of Approval: The letter of approval from host country is basic step for every CDM project and in PDD there is no letter attached. PDD says, “The letter of approval from the party involved in the project activity is not available at the time of submitting the PDD to the validating DOE.”  So in absence of approval letter the whole process turns void.

Falguni Joshi 
Gujarat forum On CDM (gujaratforumoncdm@gmail.com) 
(Gujarat Forum on CDM – is a network of Individuals & Organisations working on Environmental issue & Monitoring of CDM projects in Gujarat, India.)
Submitted by: Gujarat Forum on CDM 
Gujarat forum on CDM respectfully submit the following comments on the Project Design Document (PDD) for Wind Power Project by Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. At village : Vanchhu, Dist: Jamnagar and village: Kuchhadi, Dist:  Porbandar, Gujarat state, India.

1.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Organized before 5 year - Stakeholder meeting for Jamnagar WEG was carried out in 2008, which can not be valid now. 
2.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Invitation method is not proper - Stakeholders were invited through invitation letter (delivered in hand) which was not a good method to involve stakeholders in the process. Local stakeholder consultation must be carried out neutrally and must involve all the stakeholders.
3.	Employment Opportunity: How many skilled/unskilled people from surrounding area were employed at this project during commissioning and operation as mentioned in social well being section? 
4.	Complain redress mechanism: What is Complaint redress mechanism of a company, in case of villagers want to complain about wind mills?
5.	Location Criteria: Please explain location selection criteria.
6.	Letter of Approval: The letter of approval from host country is basic step for every CDM project and in PDD there is no letter attached. PDD says, “The letter of approval from the party involved in the project activity is not available at the time of submitting the PDD to the validating DOE.”  So in absence of approval letter the whole process turns void.

Falguni Joshi 
Gujarat forum On CDM (gujaratforumoncdm@gmail.com) 
(Gujarat Forum on CDM – is a network of Individuals & Organisations working on Environmental issue & Monitoring of CDM projects in Gujarat, India.)
Submitted by: Gujarat Forum on CDM 
Gujarat forum on CDM respectfully submit the following comments on the Project Design Document (PDD) for Wind Power Project by Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. At village : Vanchhu, Dist: Jamnagar and village: Kuchhadi, Dist:  Porbandar, Gujarat state, India.

1.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Organized before 5 year - Stakeholder meeting for Jamnagar WEG was carried out in 2008, which can not be valid now. 
2.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Invitation method is not proper - Stakeholders were invited through invitation letter (delivered in hand) which was not a good method to involve stakeholders in the process. Local stakeholder consultation must be carried out neutrally and must involve all the stakeholders.
3.	Employment Opportunity: How many skilled/unskilled people from surrounding area were employed at this project during commissioning and operation as mentioned in social well being section? 
4.	Complain redress mechanism: What is Complaint redress mechanism of a company, in case of villagers want to complain about wind mills?
5.	Location Criteria: Please explain location selection criteria.
6.	Letter of Approval: The letter of approval from host country is basic step for every CDM project and in PDD there is no letter attached. PDD says, “The letter of approval from the party involved in the project activity is not available at the time of submitting the PDD to the validating DOE.”  So in absence of approval letter the whole process turns void.

Falguni Joshi 
Gujarat forum On CDM (gujaratforumoncdm@gmail.com) 
(Gujarat Forum on CDM – is a network of Individuals & Organisations working on Environmental issue & Monitoring of CDM projects in Gujarat, India.)
Submitted by: Gujarat Forum on CDM 
Gujarat forum on CDM respectfully submit the following comments on the Project Design Document (PDD) for Wind Power Project by Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. At village : Vanchhu, Dist: Jamnagar and village: Kuchhadi, Dist:  Porbandar, Gujarat state, India.

1.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Organized before 5 year - Stakeholder meeting for Jamnagar WEG was carried out in 2008, which can not be valid now. 
2.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Invitation method is not proper - Stakeholders were invited through invitation letter (delivered in hand) which was not a good method to involve stakeholders in the process. Local stakeholder consultation must be carried out neutrally and must involve all the stakeholders.
3.	Employment Opportunity: How many skilled/unskilled people from surrounding area were employed at this project during commissioning and operation as mentioned in social well being section? 
4.	Complain redress mechanism: What is Complaint redress mechanism of a company, in case of villagers want to complain about wind mills?
5.	Location Criteria: Please explain location selection criteria.
6.	Letter of Approval: The letter of approval from host country is basic step for every CDM project and in PDD there is no letter attached. PDD says, “The letter of approval from the party involved in the project activity is not available at the time of submitting the PDD to the validating DOE.”  So in absence of approval letter the whole process turns void.

Falguni Joshi 
Gujarat forum On CDM (gujaratforumoncdm@gmail.com) 
(Gujarat Forum on CDM – is a network of Individuals & Organisations working on Environmental issue & Monitoring of CDM projects in Gujarat, India.)
Submitted by: Gujarat Forum on CDM 
Gujarat forum on CDM respectfully submit the following comments on the Project Design Document (PDD) for Wind Power Project by Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. At village : Vanchhu, Dist: Jamnagar and village: Kuchhadi, Dist:  Porbandar, Gujarat state, India.

1.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Organized before 5 year - Stakeholder meeting for Jamnagar WEG was carried out in 2008, which can not be valid now. 
2.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Invitation method is not proper - Stakeholders were invited through invitation letter (delivered in hand) which was not a good method to involve stakeholders in the process. Local stakeholder consultation must be carried out neutrally and must involve all the stakeholders.
3.	Employment Opportunity: How many skilled/unskilled people from surrounding area were employed at this project during commissioning and operation as mentioned in social well being section? 
4.	Complain redress mechanism: What is Complaint redress mechanism of a company, in case of villagers want to complain about wind mills?
5.	Location Criteria: Please explain location selection criteria.
6.	Letter of Approval: The letter of approval from host country is basic step for every CDM project and in PDD there is no letter attached. PDD says, “The letter of approval from the party involved in the project activity is not available at the time of submitting the PDD to the validating DOE.”  So in absence of approval letter the whole process turns void.

Falguni Joshi 
Gujarat forum On CDM (gujaratforumoncdm@gmail.com) 
(Gujarat Forum on CDM – is a network of Individuals & Organisations working on Environmental issue & Monitoring of CDM projects in Gujarat, India.)
Submitted by: Gujarat Forum on CDM 
Gujarat forum on CDM respectfully submit the following comments on the Project Design Document (PDD) for Wind Power Project by Gujarat Multi Gas Base Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. At village : Vanchhu, Dist: Jamnagar and village: Kuchhadi, Dist:  Porbandar, Gujarat state, India.

1.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Organized before 5 year - Stakeholder meeting for Jamnagar WEG was carried out in 2008, which can not be valid now. 
2.	Local Stakeholder Consultation: Invitation method is not proper - Stakeholders were invited through invitation letter (delivered in hand) which was not a good method to involve stakeholders in the process. Local stakeholder consultation must be carried out neutrally and must involve all the stakeholders.
3.	Employment Opportunity: How many skilled/unskilled people from surrounding area were employed at this project during commissioning and operation as mentioned in social well being section? 
4.	Complain redress mechanism: What is Complaint redress mechanism of a company, in case of villagers want to complain about wind mills?
5.	Location Criteria: Please explain location selection criteria.
6.	Letter of Approval: The letter of approval from host country is basic step for every CDM project and in PDD there is no letter attached. PDD says, “The letter of approval from the party involved in the project activity is not available at the time of submitting the PDD to the validating DOE.”  So in absence of approval letter the whole process turns void.

Falguni Joshi 
Gujarat forum On CDM (gujaratforumoncdm@gmail.com) 
(Gujarat Forum on CDM – is a network of Individuals & Organisations working on Environmental issue & Monitoring of CDM projects in Gujarat, India.)
Submitted by: Gujarat Forum on CDM

The comment period is over.
* Emission reductions in metric tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum that are based on the estimates provided by the project participants in unvalidated PDDs