19:47 16 Nov 26
Info Report Check
Submission incomplete:
1: The DOE is requested to describe the steps taken to assess the identification of the baseline scenario of the project activity as per VVM v1.2 paragraph 87.
In particular, the DOE shall provide validation opinion on why baseline alternative F2 (the continuation of the current practice) has not been identified as the most plausible baseline scenario considering that the fuel mix reflects the real fuel consumption of the cement plant in the past three years and it is a more conservative (in terms of less emissions) baseline alternative in comparison with F3 (the fossil fuels with a different fuel mix).
2: The DOE is requested to describe the steps taken to assess the equations applied to calculate the baseline/ project emissions, leakage and emission reductions as per the chosen methodology as per VVM v1.2 paragraph 92.
In particular, the DOE shall provide validation on the calculation of the leakage related to the use of the biomass residues considering the PP/DOE has not reported the quantity of biomass residues that are utilized within the region, and it is not clear the quantity of available biomass residues in the region is 25% larger than the quantity of biomass residues that are utilized.
3: The DOE is requested to include information on how it has validated the input values to the financial calculations as per VVM v 1.2 paragraph 114 (a).
In particular, the DOE shall provide a further validation opinion on the suitability of the fuel consumption applied in the IRR calculation considering that such amount is different from the historical data (52% of natural gas, 46% of petcoke) provided by the PP. In doing so, the DOE should further explain why the amount used in the IRR calculation was considered appropriate and conservative in the context of the project activity.
1: The DOE is requested to describe the steps taken to assess the identification of the baseline scenario of the project activity as per VVM v1.2 paragraph 87.
In particular, the DOE shall provide validation opinion on why baseline alternative F2 (the continuation of the current practice) has not been identified as the most plausible baseline scenario considering that the fuel mix reflects the real fuel consumption of the cement plant in the past three years and it is a more conservative (in terms of less emissions) baseline alternative in comparison with F3 (the fossil fuels with a different fuel mix).
2: The DOE is requested to describe the steps taken to assess the equations applied to calculate the baseline/ project emissions, leakage and emission reductions as per the chosen methodology as per VVM v1.2 paragraph 92.
In particular, the DOE shall provide validation on the calculation of the leakage related to the use of the biomass residues considering the PP/DOE has not reported the quantity of biomass residues that are utilized within the region, and it is not clear the quantity of available biomass residues in the region is 25% larger than the quantity of biomass residues that are utilized.
3: The DOE is requested to include information on how it has validated the input values to the financial calculations as per VVM v 1.2 paragraph 114 (a).
In particular, the DOE shall provide a further validation opinion on the suitability of the fuel consumption applied in the IRR calculation considering that such amount is different from the historical data (52% of natural gas, 46% of petcoke) provided by the PP. In doing so, the DOE should further explain why the amount used in the IRR calculation was considered appropriate and conservative in the context of the project activity.

Offset now: visit the United Nations Carbon Offset Platform
Connect with us: