Info Report Check
Submission incomplete:
1: The DOE is requested to provide information on how it has validated the evidence provided for prior consideration of CDM as per VVM v 1.2 paragraph 104(b).
The DOE is requested to report on how it has reviewed the prior consideration form sent to the DNA and the confirmation received from the DNA since the final validation report ( page 25) reported only regarding the form sent to the UNFCCC and the confirmation received from the UNFCCC.

2: The DOE is requested to confirm the accuracy of the financial calculations carried out for the investment analysis as per VVM v 1.2 paragraph 114 (c).
Please report on how the fair value of the equipments at the end of the project lifetime had been considered by the PP in the investment analysis given that only land price has been considered as the other income in the investment analysis ( IRR tab_cell W33 of investment analysis sheet).

3: The DOE is requested to include information on how it has validated the input values to the financial calculations as per VVM v 1.2 paragraph 114 (a).
Please respond to the following issues/concerns : (i) The DOE is requested to report why escalation of 5% is considered for annual O&M cost only where as the income for the project (electricity tariff) has been kept as fixed; (ii) The DOE is requested to report on what basis the similar CDM projects were identified to have comparative assessment of the input values to the investment analysis? Please provide information regarding the identified similar projects.

4: The DOE is requested to provide information on how it has validated the suitability of the benchmark as per VVM v 1.2 paragraph 114 (b).
Information is required on how the DOE has validated the suitability of vintage year for BSE-500 Index data and Beta value given that the vintage year of BSE-500 index data and beta value is only for 11.25 years from February 1999 24/05/2010 and 5 year period from 01/05/2005 -31/04/2010 respectively whereas the financial analysis is performed for a 20 year operation period