Info Report Check
Submission incomplete:
1: The PP/DOE are requested to describe in the PDD how each applicability condition of the methodology(ies) and/or the selected standardize baseline(s) is met as per PS version 09.0 paragraph 39.
The applicability criterion referred in the section B.2. refer to the applicability criterion of the version 17 of AMS-I.D while the PDD and the validation report state that the version 18 of AMS-I.D has been applied.

2: The DOE is requested to describe the steps taken to validate the accuracy and completeness of the project description and confirm that the CDM project activity is not a CPA that has been excluded from a registered PoA as per VVS version 09.0 paragraphs 71-76 and 77 (a) (b).
The paragraph 76 of the VVS version 9 states that " The DOE shall confirm that the proposed CDM project activity or CPA is not a CPA that has been excluded from a registered CDM PoA as a result of erroneous inclusion of CPAs." However, the DOE did not provide any information on this requirement.

3: The DOE is requested to describe how each applicability condition of the methodology/ies and/or the standardized baseline(s) is fulfilled by the project activity as per VVS version 09.0 paragraphs 85 and 86.
The DOE states that the project activity fulfils the requirement of the applied methodology AMS.I.D Version 18.The DOE is required to provide further information on how it validated the applicability conditions of the version 18 of AMS-I.D as the PDD refers to the applicability conditions of version 17.

4: The DOE is requested to describe how it has validated the evidence provided for prior consideration of CDM and the real and continuing actions, if applicable, as per VVS version 09.0 paragraph 120 (b).
The DOE validated that the prior consideration form of " Birla Corporation Limited", "Porwal Auto Components Ltd.", "Bidar Solar Power Pvt. Ltd" and "Gupta Sons" were sent to the secretariat and the DNA on 05/03/13, 03/07/13, 29/03/14 and 02/02/12 accordingly. However, the website for the prior consideration of the CDM (https://cdm.unfccc.int/Projects/PriorCDM/notifications/index_html) only provides that "Porwal Auto Components Ltd" and "Bidar Solar Power Pvt. Ltd" sent the notification on 3 July 2013 and 29/03/14. The DOE is required to provide further information on how it validated the prior consideration for "Birla Corporation Limited" and "Gupta Sons".

5: The DOE is requested to verify the justification and appropriateness of the fixed data and parameters used for the emission reduction calculations as per VVS version 09.0 paragraphs 142 (a), 144 (a) (b) (c) and 145.
The DOE (p 15) states that "Baseline emission factor of NEWNE Grid is establish ex-ante based on Tool to calculate the grid emission factor, using a combined approach consisting 75% operating margin and 25% build margin." However, the PDD establishes the ex-ante baseline grid emission factor of both NEWNE grid and the Southern grid.

6: The DOE is requested to describe how it has assessed the adequacy of the local stakeholder consultation and how comments have taken in due account as per VVS version 09.0 paragraphs 162-165 and 166.
The PDD states that the local consultation was held on 25/08/2014 for Birla Corporation Limited, 28/08/2014 for Porwal Auto Components Ltd, 27/08/2014 for Bidar Solar Power Pvt. Ltd and 29/08/2014 for Gupta Sons. The DOE (p 16) states that "the start date of the proposed project activity is 05/03/2012." The DOE is required to provide further information on how it validated the local stakeholder consultation as per the para 162(d) of VVS which states that the consultation process is completed before the start date of the proposed CDM project activity.